She used to sit outside under the oak tree, her head resting back against the trunk, hands cushioned behind, eyes tilted heavenward, searching for butterflies. Of course this only happened during spring, and it was most convenient to do it after Saturday morning breakfast, when the sun was still warm. Living out in the open, next to the river, there was always a good chance of seeing at least one or two, either the Painted Lady, or the Buckeye, or if she was lucky, the Ulysses. She didnât know the scientific names back then, they had real names, like Tinkerbell, Misty and Sir Geoffrey. Sometimes they wouldnât show up and sheâd be content to move off under the tree and go play inside the house.
But childlike wonder soon turns into a hobbie, or an academic pursuit of some kind. Armed with books and internet searches it was not enough just to wait and watch, it had to be categorised. She used to draw them, Sir Geoffrey playing with Tinkerbell. Of course they never actually appeared together, but in her young mind they did, and they were going to get married too one day. Now beauty was under the magnifying glass, or at least at this stage, studied in books and cropped out of digital photos. The biological motives for the circles on the wings obscured the childhood fantasy that they were just there to make the sky a prettier place. Like the blue spring sky needed a dash of color to go along with the smell of spring blossoms.
Soon after that Sir Geoffrey was under a magnifying glass, spread out, pins piercing the wings so that the microscope could peer into the patterns. Funny, the rising suns on the wings didnât have the same contrast against the harsh bulb as it did on the blue sky. They also no longer winked at her when the wings beat, they were now motionless, of course. It may seem cruel, she reasoned to her herself, but itâs better than those who catch butterflies to keep them in a jar. Surely thatâs worse? At least like this she can frame Sir Geoffrey, for anyone to see, conveniently, whenever they felt the need. She had captured beauty you see, and now that it was her possession she could gaze on it when she wanted, she could display itâs beauty to the world without having to get them to sit under a tree for an hour first. Surely?
But as with most hobbies they eventually fade away, and along with it the color from Geoffreyâs wings as he lay crucified in his glass frame, dusty now, hanging above the stairs, next to the overexposed photo of the beach. You see beauty captured is lost, it can only be maintained in freedom. The only way she could continue to enjoy the beauty of butterflies was to create a garden for them to live in, a place they could beat their wings against a blue sky. Beauty is no-one’s possession, for if possessed it cannot be free, and if not free to beat itâs wings against a blue sky then itâs beauty disappears, along with the sky.
She learnt this the hard way, when she was old enough to be noticed, to be beautiful, to be pursued with the purpose of being caught and displayed. And the beauty faded, and along with it the beauty of the space she occupied. Perhaps he should have played with butterflies, and realised that beauty is no man’s possession, and that perhaps he should rather have created a garden for her to live in, safe, with sun, and shade and blossoms where need be. Beauty does not need to be possessed, but rather set free to be enjoyed, in a safe, warm place. A place where sir Geoffrey and Tinkerbell may be married someday.


